I just finished both scenarios of silent Hill 2 from the SH HD collection. First of all just building off of my review of SH3 I had no idea that the voices in that version were not original. But in SH2 you can choose either OG or new voice acting tracks. I picked the original. The voice acting was meh either way.
The story is fantastic for the main scenario and it is a very enjoyable game with multiple endings incase you want to replay the fuck out of this game. The game does have its flaws.
It has ps2 flaws and ps3 flaws. The camera and lighting-Jesus christ man at certain points because of the camera angles and the lighting I straight couldnt see shit. I had to go up to the TV to see things a bunch of times. Or just walk along the wall pressing x until a door opened or he picked up the item etc. The sub scenario is way worse cuz they dont give you a light (or atleast I did not find one). All I could see was Maria and the rest of the screen was black and even going up close with my face I could not see anything. Obviously these were ps2 flaws.
The story for the sub scenario was kind of meh. I dont think I will ever play it again. It was short and I honestly straight didnt give a fuck about the sub scenarios story.
The PS3 flaws in SH2 arent as bad as SH3. The "HD upgrade" of the graphics look acceptable to me. I thought the cut scenes looked good. I had very little lagging issues in both scenarios of SH2. SH3 lagginess was way worse. The common gripe I read with other reviews is the fog doesnt look good. I thought the fog was very acceptable. Also the audio being out of the sync with characters lips moving during the cutscenes was not noticeable (If it even happened) like it was in the SH3 portion of the collection.
This HD collection isnt a knock out of the park homerun like the MGS HD collection was. But if you want to play SH2 and SH3 this is the cheapest way to go. Otherwise get ready to have your wallet raped for the PS2 copies. Or grab a xbox copy of SH2. Everyone complains about the issues and they make all these comparison videos about it. Unless you are looking for issues like that with a fine tooth comb you will be fine. I thought this version was completely acceptable.
I have a copy of SH2 for xbox. I chose to review and play the Ps3 HD collection version because the xbox seems to be on life support.
I also have SH4 for both ps2 and xbox. I manged to obtain a ps2 but it is also on life support. I am going to review SH4 for ps2 and hopefully my ps2 will survive so I can finish the game. Otherwise I will try for the xbox version as a backup plan. It will be my first time playing it. So stay tuned ya cunts.